U.S. District Judge Louis L. Stanton for the Southern District of New York ruled on Thursday that Google, parent company of YouTube, must turn over 12 Terabytes of user data logs. It’s part of the discovery process that Viacom is doing in its $1 Billion lawsuit to prove that YouTube is hosting pirated videos from its collection.
Viacom is also getting all the videos YouTube ever removed for whatever reason. While this might help Viacom show that pirated videos were at one time hosted, it may show that YouTube was making efforts to combat it if there are any timestamps included with the inclusion and subsequent deletion of said pirated videos.
However, Viacom wanted more which it didn’t get. Viacom wanted YouTube’s proprietary search function source code as well as YouTube’s new “Video ID” program. In both cases, the argument from Viacom was that YouTube skewed their search results to show pirated videos and at the very least, perhaps Viacom can offer suggestions on how to help filter out said pirated videos. The judge denied Viacom on these two fronts, protecting Google’s Intellectual Property.
Finally, Viacom wanted a copy of every video ever put up in a private account. The judge, again, ruled against that citing the Electronic Communications Privacy Act.